Hmm. You all know the books better than me, but then again I'm only to Cirith Ungol in TTT. Got a ways to go. And, eykar, I wasn't meaning anorexic, just to let you know. Rabidsamfan said what I meant. I think that whole skinny female stuff is way too much emphasized in Hollywood. I know I wouldn't want to be that skinny. I have no problem with a chunkier Frodo because I know how Hobbits are supposed to be.